(header) (header) (header)
The Stationery Office
(header)
  Home | Command Papers | House Papers | Departmental Papers | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | Links
(shadow) (shadow) (shadow) (shadow)
 

Contents

Previous

Next

The Investigation of Events that followed the death of Cyril Mark Isaacs
(rule)

CHAPTER 33

The Corsellis collection

Introduction

This chapter provides a short account of the work of Professor Corsellis who began to collect brains at Runwell Hospital in 1950. The Corsellis (or Runwell) collection is now held by the West London Mental Health NHS Trust.
The Corsellis brain collection was the first in this country. It began as an accumulation of brains that had all been referred for diagnostic reasons. Although every brain was well documented there is uncertainty about the extent to which brains from Coroner's post mortems were collected in the early years, and of any agreements with Coroners.
Purpose of the Corsellis (or Runwell Hospital) collection
In 1950 Dr Corsellis was Consultant Pathologist at Runwell Hospital in Essex. Runwell was a long-stay mental hospital with a large population of institutionalised patients with neuropsychiatric conditions. At that time there was no effective treatment for many of these conditions. Very little was known about the causes of mental diseases. Many patients had been in hospital for years.
When a patient in Runwell Hospital died, a post mortem was almost always carried out for diagnostic reasons. The original brains in the collection were examined by Dr Corsellis as an integral part of the post mortem. Instead of disposing of the brains after he had examined them, Dr Corsellis retained those that were of diagnostic interest.
No brains in the collection were obtained solely for research. To be of any value, the medical history of the deceased was always obtained and each brain was fully examined histologically. This applied irrespective of whether the brain was from a hospital or Coroner's post mortem. Brains showing features of significance were retained. 'Control' brains were also collected when neither the patient's history nor the post mortem findings indicated any neuro-psychiatric disease.
From diagnostic collection to research archive
As early as 1953, the Medical Research Council awarded Dr Corsellis a grant for his research on the collection.
Later, as the number of brains increased, the value of the collection for further research and teaching was recognised. In this way an accumulation of brains referred for diagnosis evolved over the following decades to become an invaluable research archive.
A paper written in 1994 summarises the early history of the collection:
'Brain collection began slowly; for several years almost all specimens were from Runwell patients, although a few neurological cases were received from nearby Southend General Hospital. Later Dr Corsellis' research interest in epilepsy brought referral brains from Epileptic Colonies and over three hundred epilepsy surgery specimens from the Maudsley Hospital. By the mid 1960s the workload increased as the department flourished; neuropathological support was provided for the neurosurgical unit from Oldchurch Hospital. From 1969 Runwell also provided a post mortem service for South Ockenden Subnormality Hospital. Brains from patients with all types of mental deficiency were received until that Unit closed in 1985.
A long-term collaboration with Dr Ted Bird at Cambridge beginning in the early 1970s resulted in the world's largest collection of Huntington's brains… Large numbers of normal control brains, including over 500 nonagenarian and more than 20 centenarian specimens, were collected for investigations of normal human ageing'.
Dr Corsellis' skills as a neuropathologist
Dr Corsellis devoted his life work to research on the collection. As the importance of his research was recognised so his reputation as a neuropathologist grew. The result was that an increasing number of brains were referred to him for his expert opinion. To begin with, the referrals came mainly from the South East but later from all parts of the country. Brains that exhibited unusual features were referred for his opinion. Often these, with the agreement of the referring doctor, were added to the collection.
Dr Corsellis' then unique experience was recognised by his appointment as Professor of Neuropathology at the Institute of Psychiatry and his reputation as an international authority on neuropathology became widely recognised.
When Professor Corsellis retired from his academic post at the Institute, he continued to develop the collection and his research based on it.
The collection under Dr Clive Bruton
After Professor Corsellis died in 1994, the collection continued under the leadership of his colleague, Dr Clive Bruton, who had joined the research team in 1968. Under Dr Bruton's influence the collection diversified, collecting brains of cases of Parkinson's disease, depression, and Creutzfeldt Jacob disease. When Dr Bruton died in 1996 the collection was closed. It was subsequently transferred to the West London Mental Health NHS Trust in 1997.

The significance of the Corsellis collection

Other brain collections and banks were set up following the basic pattern pioneered by Professor Corsellis in the Runwell collection. Some banks are condition-specific, others collect brains from patients with many different neuropsychiatric diseases. Some collect control brains from those who have died without any of these disorders.
Some banks act as repositories from which established research teams can request brain samples of the conditions they are investigating.
Professor Corsellis was both a pioneer and a successful researcher. To give one example, his work identified the damage to the brains of boxers from repeated blows to the head. This finding has had important consequences for the safety of both professional and amateur boxing. In amateur boxing head protection is now obligatory and the length of professional fights has been limited. This was just one of the practical benefits from Professor Corsellis' research.
Professor Corsellis' most enduring contribution was that he drew attention to the knowledge that can be acquired through painstaking investigation of the post mortem brain.

Historical features

In this short description of the origins of the Corsellis collection, two points must be emphasised:

-  the collection started 11 years before the Human Tissue Act (1961), and the procedures for collecting brains 50 years ago were entirely consistent with medical and legal requirements of that time;

-  discoveries of major clinical importance have only been possible through research based on the number and diversity of the Corsellis collection.

The importance and value of brain archives and brain collections is discussed in Chapter 46.

Summary

 
The first brain collection in England was started in 1950 by Professor Corsellis in the pathology department of a long stay mental hospital.
The bank began as an accumulation of brains referred for diagnosis but the potential value for research was soon realised.
Professor Corsellis pioneered the concept of research based on brain archives and collections.
Other brain banks have since been set up and brain bank archives have become an essential research resource.



 
       
 

Contents

Previous

Next